Lift The Bar

In the fitness industry, variety is often marketed as the key to keeping clients engaged. Scroll through social media and you’ll see endless reels of novel exercises, unusual equipment set‑ups and constantly changing session formats. Although variety has its place, relying on it as your primary coaching tool can work against both you and your clients. Effective personal training isn’t about dazzling people with an ever‑changing routine, it’s about guiding them through a structured, purposeful process that leads to tangible, meaningful progress.

For many clients, especially beginners or those lacking confidence, too much variety can feel chaotic. When every session looks completely different, they may struggle to understand what they’re working towards or whether they’re improving. Consistency builds familiarity, and familiarity builds confidence. When a client knows what to expect, and can feel themselves mastering foundational movements, they become more comfortable in their training environment and more invested in the process.

From a physiological standpoint, repetition is essential. The body adapts through repeated exposure to stress, that’s the basis of progressive overload. If exercises change too frequently, clients may never spend enough time on a movement to improve technique, strength or stability. While variety creates interest, consistency creates results. The best programmes blend both, but consistency takes priority.

Another issue with overusing variety is that it can mask a lack of programming direction. If you're constantly switching exercises to keep sessions “fun”, you might unintentionally be avoiding the deeper work of planning progression, evaluating form or tracking development over time. Structured training doesn’t need to be boring. In fact, many clients find satisfaction in honing skills, seeing their numbers rise and feeling their competence improve week after week.

A more effective approach is to think of variety as a tool, not a strategy. Rather than reinventing the entire session every week, make small, purposeful changes. Adjust reps, tempo, load, range of motion or rest periods. Introduce subtle variations within a movement pattern, e.g. a change in foot stance or grip, while keeping the core structure intact. This keeps training engaging without compromising progression.

It’s also helpful to explain the purpose of structure to your clients. Some people may come to you believing that “newer is better” because that’s what they’ve seen online. Your content can play a major role here. Share posts or blogs that highlight why repetition matters. Normalize the idea that sticking with foundational movements is not a sign of laziness or lack of creativity, it’s smart, effective training. When clients understand the “why” behind your programming decisions, their buy‑in increases dramatically.

Ultimately, relying on variety alone does your clients a disservice. What they truly need isn’t constant novelty, it’s clarity, consistency, and a sense of forward movement. Structured programming provides them with a roadmap. It shows them that their training is purposeful. It builds trust in your expertise. And in the long run, it leads to better results.

As trainers, our goal is normally to coach someone towards meaningful change, not entertain them for an hour (although there may be some exceptions, depending on what the client wants). Novel exercises will always have a place, but they should support the programme, not define it. When you strike the right balance, you empower your clients to progress confidently, safely and sustainably.

For more on similar topics LTB members can access the Foundations of general population programme design course and more (or drop Claire a message if you are looking for help on something else).

Non members* can sign up for a 2 week free trial to access this and hundreds of other videos, downloads and courses covering every aspect of becoming the personal trainer you want to be.  Sign up here

*New members only